Few seasonal dishes are as popular as pumpkin pie — as for good reason. As soon as the Georgia foliage starts to turn colors, our tastebuds start to crave this sweet delight.
If you’re a “pumpkin head,” like many people, you want to know where to get the tastiest pumpkin pies right now in Atlanta.
Here’s Where To Buy The Best Pumpkin Pies In Atlanta
Here are some locations that sell the best pumpkin pies in Atlanta, according to reviewers.
Buttermilk Sky
3145 Peachtree Rd NE suite 165, Atlanta, GA 30305
If you want to order pumpkin pie, Buttermilk Sky is a great option.
Here’s what one reviewer says about Buttermilk Sky: “Preferred Place for Pie ! Apple is my favorite, followed by their Peach Pie. The Coconut and Pecan Pies are tasty but very sweet; try with coffee.”
Southern Baked Pie Company
Atlanta Locations:
- 3145 Peachtree Rd NE suite 165, Atlanta, GA 30305 | (404) 263-0820
- 4300 Paces Ferry Rd SE #113, Atlanta, GA 30339
- 2685 Old Milton Pkwy #130, Alpharetta, GA 30009
When it comes to mail order pies, it’s hard to beat the Southern Baked Pie Company. If you order online, UPS typically delivers your within three days, but there may be a slight delay out of their control.
Here’s what one reviewer says about the Southern Baked Pie Company. “Amazing pie with amazing crust. A little price but worth it. If you are lucky enough to catch their blackberry or peach pie, which are seasonal items, stock up! The pot roast pie is amazing and decadent-tender pot roast layered with mashed potatoes. It is nothing short of incredible!”
Southern Sweets Bakery
186 Rio Cir, Decatur, GA 30030 | (404) 373-8752
Here’s what one reviewer says about Southern Sweets Bakery: “This place is amazing! I am truly thinking about going to buy some chocolate pecan tarts to take home for my family. A chef friend of mine recommended that i come here during my vacation in atl and he will now get a gold metal! It is a must try. Best pecan pie i have ever had!”
The Pie Hole
1025 Canton St, Roswell, GA 30075 | (678) 461-3776
The Pie Hole is one of the best places to order a pie for takeout in Atlanta.
Here’s what one reviewer says about The Pie Hole: “Amazing pies with a quaint atmosphere for dining inside or out on the porch. I wish it was open later so I could go after dinner for dessert. I got a slice of the thin mint pie and it was amazing!! Oreo crust and so creamy. Plus a super friendly person working the counter who helped me decide what to try.”
Kenny’s Great Pies
5200 Highlands Pkwy SE, Smyrna, GA 30082 | (770) 333-0043
One of Smyrna’s best-kept secrets is Kenny’s Great Pies, which sells some exotic creations that get rave reviews.
Here is what one reviewer says about Kenny’s Great Pies. “Not only are the pies delicious but the customer service is beyond amazing! My family loves the mango and the chocolate pies, so for our son’s birthday, we decided to have a mango pie instead of cake. When I called the corporate location to check on hours and availability, I was told that due to COVID the facility was closed for customers. I was able to contact Catherine at the facility and told her that I really wanted to get mango pie for our son’s birthday and she was very kind and arranged for us to be able to pick-up. Not only did she give us the pie but also included whipped cream and additional bite-size pies to serve as candles. She went above and beyond and truly made our day! Thank you Catherine and Kenny’s Pies.”
Looking for some autumn fun in Georgia? Don’t miss these fall festivals. Also, don’t forget to keep up with the fall foliage map.
There are so many Atlanta events popping off every week it’s hard to keep up with it all. That’s why I suggest you subscribe to AtlantaFi.com to get all the freshest gatherings, Atlanta happenings, parties and more delivered to your inbox.
Here are more articles from AtlantaFi.com: