It’s been said that Atlanta is not a real place. One reason is due to the many true-or-not-true claims associated with the city.
Is Buckhead really named after a buck’s head? Who knows. Some things about Atlanta’s history are known facts while others are kind of dubious.
6 Dubious Claims About Atlanta: Are They True Or Not?
Dubious facts are those that seem questionable, lack clear evidence, or are often repeated without verification.
Here are some dubious facts or claims about Atlanta, Georgia, that have circulated but are either unproven, exaggerated, or based on shaky grounds, along with a critical look at each:
1. Atlanta Has 71 Streets Named Peachtree
Claim: It’s often said that Atlanta has over 70 streets with “Peachtree” in their name, with numbers like 71 or 55 frequently cited.
Why It’s Dubious: While Atlanta does have many streets with “Peachtree” in their names (e.g., Peachtree Street, Peachtree Road, Peachtree Lane), the exact count varies across sources, with no definitive list verified by city records.
Some sources, like Discover Atlanta, claim around 70, while others, like Mental Floss, say 55. The lack of a precise, authoritative count suggests exaggeration or sloppy reporting.
Additionally, the idea that these streets are all named after peach trees is dubious—historians argue the name likely comes from “Standing Pitch Tree,” a Native American term for pine trees, as peach trees aren’t native to the area.
Reality: There are many Peachtree-named streets, but the exact number is unconfirmed, and the peach tree origin story is likely a myth.
2. There’s a Burial Plot Between Runways at Hartsfield-Jackson Airport
Claim: A small cemetery, sometimes called Flat Rock Cemetery, exists between two runways at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport.
Why It’s Dubious: This claim, mentioned in Reddit discussions, lacks concrete documentation from official airport or city records.
While it’s plausible that old burial sites could exist near the airport due to its large footprint and historical land use, no verified evidence confirms a cemetery between runways.
The story may stem from confusion with nearby historical cemeteries or urban legends about displaced graves during airport expansion. Without primary sources, it remains speculative.
Reality: No confirmed cemetery exists between the runways, though the airport’s vast area may include undocumented historical sites.
3. It’s Illegal to Tie a Giraffe to a Telephone Pole in Atlanta
Claim: Atlanta has an outdated law banning tying a giraffe to a telephone pole or street lamp.
Why It’s Dubious: This is often cited as a quirky, antiquated law, but there’s no evidence in Atlanta’s municipal code to support it.
Such claims typically arise from lists of “weird laws” that circulate online, often without citing original ordinances.
It’s possible this stems from misinterpretations of old animal control laws, but the specificity of “giraffe” suggests it’s more likely a fabricated or exaggerated tale.
Reality: No such law is documented in Atlanta’s legal code, making it a likely urban legend.
4. It’s Illegal to Keep a Donkey in Your Bathtub in Atlanta
Claim: An old Atlanta law supposedly prohibits keeping a donkey in a bathtub.
Why It’s Dubious: Like the giraffe law, this appears in lists of strange laws but lacks any verifiable source in Atlanta’s ordinances.
These stories often emerge from early 20th-century regulations taken out of context or entirely made up for entertainment. Without a specific citation, it’s dubious at best.
Reality: No evidence supports this as an actual law, likely another myth from “weird laws” collections.
5. Atlanta Was Named After the Governor’s Daughter’s Middle Name, Atalanta
Claim: Atlanta’s name comes from Marthasville, which was renamed after Governor Wilson Lumpkin’s daughter’s middle name, Atalanta.
Why It’s Dubious: This story competes with another claim that Atlanta is a shortened form of “Atlantica-Pacifica,” tied to the Western and Atlantic Railroad.
Both origins are cited in various sources, but neither is definitively proven.
The Atalanta story relies on anecdotal history, and no primary documents, like city charters, confirm it. The railroad explanation is more widely accepted, as Atlanta was founded as a rail terminus, but the lack of consensus keeps this claim questionable.
Reality: The railroad origin is more likely, but the Atalanta story persists without solid evidence.
6. Street Names Changed at Ponce de Leon to Separate White and Black Neighborhoods
Claim: Streets like Briarcliff and Moreland change names at Ponce de Leon Avenue because white residents didn’t want to share street names with Black neighborhoods to the south.
Why It’s Dubious: This claim, mentioned in Atlanta Magazine, lacks primary sources like city council records or firsthand accounts to confirm racial intent.
Street name changes in Atlanta often result from historical quirks, like separate towns merging or inconsistent naming conventions.
While segregation was rampant historically, attributing specific street name changes to it without evidence is speculative. It’s plausible but unproven.
Reality: Street name changes are common in Atlanta, but no hard evidence ties this specific practice to racial segregation.
These claims float around as “fun facts” but crumble under scrutiny due to lack of primary sources, reliance on anecdotal reports, or outright fabrication.
Final Word
Always cross-check such tales with official records or reputable histories to separate fact from folklore. If you want me to dig deeper into any of these or search for more dubious Atlanta claims, let me know!
Atlanta has a lot of cool things to do and places to eat, including some of the top soul food joints and remarkable Thai food spots. Explore the city.
Here are more articles from AtlantaFi.com you might like: